Jeff Horton (2003-2007)
- Set the school’s career rushing record with 3,072 yards, nearly 750 more than any other Crusader in history
- Holds Valpo’s single game rushing mark with 253 yards against Wisconsin Lutheran in 2005
- Posted marks for rushes (257) and yards (1,358) in a single season, setting both records in 2005.
Rob Giancola (2000-2004)
- Holds Valpo career records with 40 touchdowns and 3,804 receiving yards
- Set the single season receiving records in 2003 for yards (1,496) and touchdowns (23) during the PFL championship season
- Single game record-holder with 275 receiving yards as well as four receiving touchdowns (accomplished twice)